Scotch Magic Tape Vs. Scotch Gift Wrap Tape: What’s the Difference?

The key difference is Scotch Magic is designed to be invisible and permanent, while Scotch Gift Wrap Tape is decorative and best for temporary/seasonal use on presents.

Scotch Magic Tape Vs. Scotch Gift Wrap Tape

Scotch Magic Tape Vs. Scotch Gift Wrap Tape: Specs & Uses

💪Adhesive Thickness

Magic Tape: 22 microns

Gift Wrap Tape: 25 microns

🆚Key Features

Magic Tape: Invisible, matte finish; writes on easily; strong adhesive; resists discoloration

Gift Wrap Tape: Fun patterns and colors; strong adhesive; easy tear; crisp edges

🛠️Common Uses

Magic Tape can be used to fix torn paper; label food containers in the kitchen; and attach notes or memos to textbooks or workbooks.

Gift Wrap Tape is acid-free and yellowing resistant; While not as noticeable as Scotch Magic Tape, the gift wrap tape may still be visible on black matte finish gift wrap paper. For a seamless look, hot glue under the flaps is recommended.

Technical Info

Magic TapeGift Wrap Tape
Total Score★★★★★★★★★
BackingMatte cellulose acetateSatinized creped paper
AdhesiveSynthetic acrylicRubber-resin
Adhesion to Steel2.5 N/cm3.1 N/cm
Unwinding Force75 cN/cm110 cN/cm
Tensile Strength2.6 daN/cm5.4 daN/cm
Elongation at Break25%7%
Total Thickness0.060 mm0.105 mm

Scotch Magic Tape is matte and visible on surfaces while Scotch Gift Wrap Tape is satin-finished and invisible on most wrapping paper.

Review of Scotch Magic Tape

Scotch Magic Tape Product
The Scotch Magic Tape boasts a standard 1-inch core diameter, ensuring it fits seamlessly into most desktop and handheld dispensers. It’s also specifically designed to be a refill for the popular Scotch C-40 dispensers.


I’ve tried cheaper options, but they often turn out to be flimsy and thin, or discolored in some way. Scotch tape, on the other hand, is always dependable and worth the money.

Use Scotch Magic Tape on my work
Use Scotch Magic Tape on my work

Versatility is where this tape truly shines. Whether I’m working on a scrapbooking project, creating intricate paper crafts, or even assembling my son’s latest Lego Technic creation, the Scotch Magic Tape always comes through.

Its clear appearance ensures a clean, professional finish on any surface, from cardstock to wood to even my KitchenAid stand mixer (don’t judge, desperate times call for desperate measures).

Yes Paste vs. Mod Podge

Yes Paste vs. Mod Podge: Crafting, Artistic, Bond Wallpaper, Scrapbook & Decoupage Projects, Diamond Painting

Speaking of surfaces, this tape adheres remarkably well to a variety of materials, both porous and non-porous.

I’ve used it to hang decorations on my freshly painted Behr Marquee walls for my daughter’s unicorn-themed birthday party, and it held those delicate paper streamers without a hitch – no unsightly residue or paint peeling.

It’s also been a lifesaver when securing loose trims on my living room drapes. However, for heavier decorations like balloons, the adhesive strength may vary depending on factors like temperature, surface texture, and balloon movement.

Now, let’s talk about value. The standard Scotch Magic Tape pack comes with three rolls, each a generous 3/4 inches wide by 1000 inches long. That’s a whopping 3000 inches of tape in total!

Considering the versatility and quality, this product is an absolute steal. There’s some confusion around whether it’s 1000 inches per roll or total, but I can confirm it’s 1000 inches per roll for that 3-pack.

But what if you need even more tape? No problem! Scotch offers refill packs designed specifically for their C-40 dispensers, ensuring a seamless refilling process. And for those with unique dispenser needs, like the 2 3/4-inch core diameter my crafting buddy uses, there are options available from other brands at stores like Walmart to accommodate.

❌Difficult to Detect

Scotch Magic Tape on the table

The tape itself is clear and becomes difficult to detect once you quickly rub a finger over it. It also doesn’t show when copied with one of those newfangled copy machines.

Scotch Magic Tape

💬 FAQ: Scotch Magic Tape

Q: Will the tape dispenser work with a tape that is 300 yards long and 3/4 inch wide?

A: Yes, this tape will fit the 3/4″ X 300 yards tape dispenser.

Q: Can I use this tape refill with my dispenser that requires a 1″ core diameter?

A: Yes, this tape has a 1″ core diameter, so it should fit your dispenser perfectly.

Q: Is this tape refill compatible with the C40 dispenser?

A: Yes, this tape refill is compatible with the C40 dispenser.

Q: What is the difference between the .16 rolls and the .3/4 x 1000 inches rolls?

A: I haven’t seen a .16 roll, but the 3/4 roll is .75 inches wide. If the other roll is .16, it would be much narrower.

CTA:list all comments

2 reviews

    • There are several factors to consider, including the size and weight of the balloons, the type of paint on the wall, the temperature of the room, any drafts that may cause the balloons to move, the length of the string, and the amount of tape used. It may be best to consult with the store where you are purchasing the…Read More

📣🔥 Share it to easily keep track of the answers!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

My Hands-on Test: Scotch Gift Wrap Tape

Scotch Gift Wrap Tape Product
Every year during the holidays, I find myself running out of tape while wrapping presents. So this year, I ordered the Scotch Magic Tape 6-Pack to hopefully avoid that problem. The tape arrived quickly, and I was impressed with its quality.

✅Pros: Scotch Gift Wrap Tape

First things first, let’s address the elephant in the room – the dispensers. While it might seem like a waste of plastic, these little guys are surprisingly handy.

I used to transfer the tape to a separate Black Scotch Dispenser, but that was a hassle. Now, I simply use the dispenser that comes with each roll, and let me tell you, it makes the whole process a breeze. However, it’s important to note that these dispensers are not refillable, so once a roll is used up, you’ll need to switch to a new one.

Scotch Gift Wrap Tape and a dispenser

Speaking of the rolls, each one offers a generous 18 yards (16.5m) of tape, ensuring you have plenty to work with. The Amazon listing clearly states it’s 650 inches per individual roll, not the total for the 6-pack. And the best part? It’s manufactured right here in St. Paul, Minnesota, by the good folks at 3M.

Now, let’s talk about the tape itself. This satin-finish beauty is a game-changer when it comes to wrapping gifts. It blends seamlessly with most wrapping papers, creating a polished and professional look.

Alien Tape vs. Command Strips vs. Mounting Tape: Brick surfaces, Thick Garland, Bird Spikes

Alien Tape vs. Command Strips vs. Mounting Tape: Brick surfaces, Thick Garland, Bird Spikes

But what really sets this tape apart is its versatility. Sure, it’s not designed for heavy-duty repairs (for that, I’d recommend a sturdy duct tape like the trusty Trex Duck Tape), but it’s perfect for those times when you need to secure a torn piece of paper or reinforce a seam.

Trex Tape vs Gorilla Tape

(Duct Tape)Trex Tape vs Gorilla Tape: Seal Leaky Hoses, Tarps & Outdoor Equipment

And for all my left-handed friends out there, fear not! While Scotch doesn’t offer dedicated left-handed scissors, their classic Scotch Scissors handles are designed for ambidextrous use, so you can cut and wrap with ease, no matter your dominant hand.

I have to admit, when I saw the price tag of $35 for a 6-pack, I was a bit taken aback. But after experiencing the quality and convenience of this tape, I can confidently say it’s worth every penny.

Plus, with Amazon’s pricing fluctuations, you might just snag a deal like I did – I got mine for $7.66! However, if you ever encounter a price difference between what you paid and the listed price, you’ll need to reach out to the seller directly for any potential credit, as Amazon doesn’t handle that.

As for recyclability, the dispensers have a recycling code of 6, so be sure to check with your local recycling center if they can accept #6 plastic items.

❌One Final Note

If you’re planning to wrap black matte (chalkboard) gift wrap paper, this tape might not be your best bet. While it blends better than the Magic Tape, hot glue under the flaps is your best option for a seamless finish.

Scotch Gift Wrap Tape Product

💬 FAQ: Scotch Gift Wrap Tape

Q: Can the black dispensers be used with refill rolls of the Scotch Magic Tape?

A: Unfortunately, refill rolls for the black dispensers are not available. However, you can transfer the tape from the refill rolls to the dispenser, although the rolls are shorter and the plastic packaging is still wasted.

Q: Is Scotch gift wrap tape acid-free and resistant to yellowing?

A: I’ve been using Scotch gift wrap tape for a long time, and so far, I haven’t noticed any yellowing or signs of acidity. Therefore, I would say that the tape is not likely to yellow.

Q: Can the dispensers be recycled?

A: The dispensers have a recycling code of 6, but it is best to check with your local recycling center to see if they accept #6 plastic items.

Q: What is the difference between Scotch gift wrap tape and Scotch Magic Tape?

A: The primary difference between Scotch gift wrap tape and Scotch Magic Tape is the finish. Gift wrap tape has a satin finish, while Magic tape has a matte finish.

Q: Is Scotch gift wrap tape safe for walls and paint?

A: Scotch gift wrap tape is not recommended for use on walls as it can peel paint, depending on the type of paint and how long the tape is left in place. It is best to use tape specifically designed for walls to avoid any damage.