Scotch Magic Tape Vs. Scotch Gift Wrap Tape: Repair Torn Paper, Labeling Containers & Attach Images

Scotch Magic Tape Vs. Scotch Gift Wrap Tape: What’s the Difference?

Scotch Magic Tape Vs. Scotch Gift Wrap Tape: Specs & Uses

Technical Info

	Magic Tape	Gift Wrap Tape
Total Score	★★★★	★★★★★
Backing	Matte cellulose acetate	Satinized creped paper
Adhesive	Synthetic acrylic	Rubber-resin
Adhesion to Steel	2.5 N/cm	3.1 N/cm
Unwinding Force	75 cN/cm	110 cN/cm
Tensile Strength	2.6 daN/cm	5.4 daN/cm
Elongation at Break	25%	7%
Total Thickness	0.060 mm	0.105 mm

Scotch Magic Tape is matte and visible on surfaces while Scotch Gift Wrap Tape is satin-finished and invisible on most wrapping paper.

Review of Scotch Magic Tape

✅Pros

I’ve tried cheaper options, but they often turn out to be flimsy and thin, or discolored in some way. Scotch tape, on the other hand, is always dependable and worth the money.

Versatility is where this tape truly shines. Whether I’m working on a scrapbooking project, creating intricate paper crafts, or even assembling my son’s latest Lego Technic creation, the Scotch Magic Tape always comes through.

Its clear appearance ensures a clean, professional finish on any surface, from cardstock to wood to even my KitchenAid stand mixer (don’t judge, desperate times call for desperate measures).

Speaking of surfaces, this tape adheres remarkably well to a variety of materials, both porous and non-porous.

I’ve used it to hang decorations on my freshly painted Behr Marquee walls for my daughter’s unicorn-themed birthday party, and it held those delicate paper streamers without a hitch – no unsightly residue or paint peeling.

It’s also been a lifesaver when securing loose trims on my living room drapes. However, for heavier decorations like balloons, the adhesive strength may vary depending on factors like temperature, surface texture, and balloon movement.

Now, let’s talk about value. The standard Scotch Magic Tape pack comes with three rolls, each a generous 3/4 inches wide by 1000 inches long. That’s a whopping 3000 inches of tape in total!

Considering the versatility and quality, this product is an absolute steal. There’s some confusion around whether it’s 1000 inches per roll or total, but I can confirm it’s 1000 inches per roll for that 3-pack.

But what if you need even more tape? No problem! Scotch offers refill packs designed specifically for their C-40 dispensers, ensuring a seamless refilling process. And for those with unique dispenser needs, like the 2 3/4-inch core diameter my crafting buddy uses, there are options available from other brands at stores like Walmart to accommodate.

❌Difficult to Detect

The tape itself is clear and becomes difficult to detect once you quickly rub a finger over it. It also doesn’t show when copied with one of those newfangled copy machines.

💬 FAQ: Scotch Magic Tape

My Hands-on Test: Scotch Gift Wrap Tape

✅Pros: Scotch Gift Wrap Tape

First things first, let’s address the elephant in the room – the dispensers. While it might seem like a waste of plastic, these little guys are surprisingly handy.

I used to transfer the tape to a separate Black Scotch Dispenser, but that was a hassle. Now, I simply use the dispenser that comes with each roll, and let me tell you, it makes the whole process a breeze. However, it’s important to note that these dispensers are not refillable, so once a roll is used up, you’ll need to switch to a new one.

Speaking of the rolls, each one offers a generous 18 yards (16.5m) of tape, ensuring you have plenty to work with. The Amazon listing clearly states it’s 650 inches per individual roll, not the total for the 6-pack. And the best part? It’s manufactured right here in St. Paul, Minnesota, by the good folks at 3M.

Now, let’s talk about the tape itself. This satin-finish beauty is a game-changer when it comes to wrapping gifts. It blends seamlessly with most wrapping papers, creating a polished and professional look.

But what really sets this tape apart is its versatility. Sure, it’s not designed for heavy-duty repairs (for that, I’d recommend a sturdy duct tape like the trusty Trex Duck Tape), but it’s perfect for those times when you need to secure a torn piece of paper or reinforce a seam.

And for all my left-handed friends out there, fear not! While Scotch doesn’t offer dedicated left-handed scissors, their classic Scotch Scissors handles are designed for ambidextrous use, so you can cut and wrap with ease, no matter your dominant hand.

I have to admit, when I saw the price tag of $35 for a 6-pack, I was a bit taken aback. But after experiencing the quality and convenience of this tape, I can confidently say it’s worth every penny.

Plus, with Amazon’s pricing fluctuations, you might just snag a deal like I did – I got mine for $7.66! However, if you ever encounter a price difference between what you paid and the listed price, you’ll need to reach out to the seller directly for any potential credit, as Amazon doesn’t handle that.

As for recyclability, the dispensers have a recycling code of 6, so be sure to check with your local recycling center if they can accept #6 plastic items.

❌One Final Note

If you’re planning to wrap black matte (chalkboard) gift wrap paper, this tape might not be your best bet. While it blends better than the Magic Tape, hot glue under the flaps is your best option for a seamless finish.

💬 FAQ: Scotch Gift Wrap Tape